At What Cost?


Without funding, we can't function. Without a plan, we shut down. When working on the latest appropriations bill - a bill with regards to spending - Congress had the tight deadline of Friday at midnight to get the passed bill to the desk of the President in order to avoid a Government shutdown.

Unfortunately in this case, Congress was unable to pass the necessary spending bill prior to the deadline and thus, the government shutdown that lasted the weekend. So, who is to blame for the the shutdown? Well, depending on who you ask, there are people on both sides of the line to blame. However, either way, what ever happened to putting the American people first? Doesn't the Constitution state of the people, by the people, for the people? So when did every government decision become about furthering party agendas and ensuring reelection?

Both parties knew that with the nearing deadline to pass the new spending bill, it served as the perfect opportunity to sell their own agendas in order to avoid a government shutdown. Now government shutdowns do not result in the entire government stopping (military and law enforcement does not stop), rather all "nonessential" government employees are sent home without pay, which makes up roughly 40% of non-military employees, only the shutdown merely lasted the weekend, both parties agreeing on a bill to re-open the government Monday afternoon. So what was the cause for all of this turmoil that most of America deemed unnecessary?

Progressive activists, who have been advocates for DREAMers (recipients of DACA) have recently been demanding that Democrats fight harder to renew DACA - a program protecting undocumented immigrants who came to America as children - they believed that Democrats were not doing everything they could to help the recipients. Democrats realized that with the nearing appropriation bill deadline, they now had leverage over Republicans. They could merely refuse to pass the bill, knowing that without any Democrat votes the bill wouldn't make it through the Senate and force a government shutdown if Republicans refused to put DACA in the bill. Sure enough, during the Friday vote, not a single Democrat voted for the bill and just as planned the bill failed in the Senate, forcing the government shutdown. However, it was not solely the Democratic agenda that caused the shutdown.


Republicans knew that with the press for time, Democrats would bring up the reinstatement of DACA, which many Republicans believe President Obama did not have the authority to instate in the first place, and thus slid a few incentives into the bill. When writing the bill, House and Senate Republicans made sure to put in incentives that would make voting 'no' a very unpopular option. The bill contained the suspension of several unpopular healthcare taxes as well as the re-authorization of CHIP - a children's health insurance policy provided to low-income families. By placing these two things into the bill, Republicans were practically daring Democrats to vote no and thus cause the government shutdown.

However, this plan hit a snag when only a few days later President Trump tweeted out that he did not support the inclusion of CHIP into the bill. This alone hurt Republicans as the backlash resulted in some House Republicans voting 'no', but when it reached the Senate, as predicted the vote was split down party lines and thus failed to go through, sealing the fate of the shutdown.

The shutdown didn't last very long though and even that was due to political agendas being carried out by our dear politicians. Each side an incentive for figuring out a quick resolution to the shutdown after both sides used the bill to try and prove a point. Democrats worried that shutting down the government for the sake of undocumented immigrants could paint them as extremists, thus hurting their chances of reelection. Many Democratic senators are facing reelection this year in traditionally "Red" states and thus this shutdown could greatly hinder their chances among the people. On the other side, Republicans face a similar motivation, as they worry their party will be blamed for the shutdown since Republicans control both Congress and the White House. This alone could hurt their chances at reelection. Since this year is the midterm elections, higher incentives are at stake as everyone knows this election will be pivotal in who controls Congress. To further complicate things for Republicans, if the government shutdown was to extend into the work week, only a week before President Trump delivers his "State of the Union Address", it would reflect very poorly on the administration.


Never mind the fact that all of this affects the lives of the American people, from the DACA decision, to the re-authorization of CHIP, and suspending the unpopular healthcare taxes, our representatives simply need to ensure reelection and party loyalty. Following the temporary agreement reached by both parties, Indivisible, a left-wing advocacy group walked to Minority Leader Chuck Schumer's house to protest saying that if they could not DREAM he would not sleep.

At what point will politicians finally put the American people first? When will policies simply reflect what the people need and not undermine the other party to further an agenda? At what point will we truly be represented?

Comments

  1. I think the most interesting part of this government shutdown, when compared to the one in 2013, was how much less inevitable this one felt. You mentioned that the deal-making process was derailed with Trump's tweet about CHIP, and I think that his inconsistent viewpoints made what should have been an easily avoidable shutdown into a partisan deadlock. We'll see how his views change the next time Congress has to pass a spending bill, three days from now, and what difference that will make.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like when you used the words "sealing the fait" which added some excess drama to what could easily be a dull topic. I also could sense a little bit of yourself when you use the sarcastic "our dear politicians" comment. This is also a good breakdown of the government shut down which was easy to understand for people who are not as politically involved such as myself.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a powerful piece, Kaitlyn! I am so glad you posted about the government shutdown, mainly because the news and media seem so concerned with pointing fingers at "who's to blame" for the shutdown, that they completely forget to share both sides of story without bias. I am glad you made this current and civic issue understandable in this post and made your passion for government truly supporting and speaking for the people evident. I think you're right: the government should be focusing more on the people instead of fixating only on reelection.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This was very informative and like mentioned above so simply put (which is amazing). Politics is an area to get easily lost in and confused and you wrote with such clarity and explanation that anyone could get a good grasp of our current political situation. I also really love the image you used in the beginning. I thought it was so funny.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This post easily summarized what the government shut down was and why it happened. I liked how you said "we are the people" which made this a very strong piece. I think it is important that everyone knows how our soldiers do not get paid when in a government shutdown. If they are out risking their lives, they should be compensated for their actions. Overall great post!

    ReplyDelete
  6. This was an excellent take on the government shutdown. It is important that we understand (as you brought up) how and why the government chooses to use political maneuvers rather than simply taking action and protecting the people. As well I very much liked your analysis of the Republican's attempt at baiting the Democrats and the Democrat attempts to countermaneuver the Republicans.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

#Delete Facebook

In Russia We Trust